Résumés
Résumé
Dans cet article nous analysons les modes de réception des parties prenantes d’une grande école de management française aux diagnostics de l’anthropocène, de l’effondrement écologique et de l’emballement climatique. Nous rendons compte plus précisément d’une innovation pédagogique qui fait provoquer une rencontre entre des savoirs académiques issus des sciences de la terre et du vivant et des étudiants en management. Nos résultats montrent comment les imaginaires écologiques et climatiques des étudiants vont être transformés suggérant une typologie des imaginaires de l’anthropocène. Nous suggérons que les expériences pédagogiques s’appuyant sur le constat de l’anthropocène ouvrent des perspectives critiques fécondes sur le management tout en produisant des situations d’apprentissage éminemment risquées.
Mots-clés :
- anthropocène,
- durabilité,
- changement climatique,
- critical management studies,
- criticité,
- redirection écologique,
- éducation au management
Abstract
In this article we analyse the ways in which stakeholders of a French graduate school of management apprehend the diagnoses of the anthropocene, ecological collapse and climate breakdown. More precisely, we describe a pedagogical innovation that brings together academic knowledge from the earth and life sciences, and management students. Our results show how students’ ecological and climatic imaginaries will be transformed, resulting in various types of anthropocenic imaginaries. We suggest that the anthropocene shifts the configuration of criticism aimed at business schools. Finally, pedagogical experiences of the anthropocene open up new critical perspectives on management but lead to risky learning situations.
Keywords:
- anthropocene,
- sustainability,
- climate change,
- critical management studies,
- criticity,
- ecological redirection,
- management education
Resumen
En este artículo analizamos las formas en que los interesados de una escuela francesa de negocios aprehenden los diagnósticos del antropoceno, el colapso ecológico y el cambio climático. Más concretamente, describimos una innovación pedagógica que aúna los conocimientos académicos de las ciencias de la tierra y los estudiantes en gestión. Nuestros resultados muestran cómo se transforman los imaginarios ecológicos y climáticos de los estudiantes, dando lugar a diversos tipos de imaginarios antropocénicos. Sugerimos que el antropoceno cambia la configuración de la crítica dirigida a las escuelas de negocios. Por último, las experiencias pedagógicas del antropoceno abren nuevas perspectivas críticas sobre la gestión, pero conducen tambien a situaciones de aprendizaje arriesgadas.
Palabras clave:
- antropoceno,
- sostenibilidad,
- cambio climático,
- estudios críticos de la gestión,
- criticidad,
- redirección ecológica,
- educación a la gestión
Parties annexes
Bibliographie
- Adams, Suzi, Smith, Jeremy, et Straume, Ingerid. Political imaginaries in question. Critical Horizons, 2012, Vol. 13, N° 1, p. 5-11.
- Alvesson, Mats et Willmott, Hugh. Critical theory and management studies : An introduction. Critical management studies, 1992, p. 1-20.
- Anderson, Damon. (2008). « Productivism, vocational and professional education, and the ecological question. » Vocations and Learning, Vol. 1, N° 2, p. 105-129.
- Anderson, Damon. (2009) Productivism and ecologism : changing discourses in TVET. In : Work, learning and sustainable development. Springer, Dordrecht. p. 35-57.
- Banerjee, Subhabrata B. Who sustains whose development ? Sustainable development and the reinvention of nature. Organization studies, 2003, Vol. 24, N° 1, p. 143-180.
- Banerjee, Subhabrata B. Corporate social responsibility : The good, the bad and the ugly. Critical sociology, 2008, Vol. 34, N° 1, p. 51-79.
- Banerjee, Subhabrata B., Jermier, John M., Peredo, Ana Maria, et al. « Theoretical perspectives on organizations and organizing in a post-growth era. » Organization, 2021, Vol. 28, N° 3, p. 337-357.
- Beaujolin-Bellet, Rachel, Grima, François (2011). « Ces enseignants chercheurs qui introduisent la critique dans les écoles de commerce françaises », dans L. Taskin et M. de Nanteuil Perspectives critiques en Management. Pour une gestion citoyenne. Bruxelles : De Boeck, p. 197-208.
- Bonnet, Emmanuel, Landivar, Diego, Monnin, Alexandre, & Allard, Laurence, (2019a). « Le design, une cosmologie sans monde face à l’Anthropocène. » Sciences du Design, (2), p. 97-104.
- Bonnet, Emmanuel, Landivar, Diego, Monnin, Alexandre (2019b). « What the anthropocene does to organizations ? », 35th EGOS 2019 Conference.
- Bonnet, Emmanuel, Landivar, Diego, Monnin, Alexandre et al. (2019c). « Les grandes écoles doivent former à la redirection écologique ». Le Monde 4 octobre 2019.
- Bonnet, Emmanuel, Landivar, Diego, Monnin, Alexandre (2021). Héritage et Fermeture. Editions Divergences.
- Bonneuil, Christophe, and Fressoz Jean-Baptiste (2013). L’événement Anthropocène : la Terre, l’histoire et nous. Seuil.
- Bottici, Chiara (2011) « From Imagination to the Imaginary and Beyond », in C. Bottici and B. Challand (eds) The Politics of Imagination, p. 16-37. London : Birckbeck Law Press.
- Bristow, Alexandra; Robinson, Sarah; Ratle, Olivier (2017). « Being an Early-Career CMS Academic in the Context of Insecurity and ‘Excellence’ : The Dialectics of Resistance and Compliance », Organization Studies, Vol. 38, N° 9, p. 1185-1207.
- Callon, Michel (2010). Performativity, misfires and politics. Journal of Cultural Economy, 3(2), p. 163-169.
- Campbell, Norah, Mchugh, Gerard, et Ennis, P. J. Climate change is not a problem : Speculative realism at the end of organization. Organization Studies, 2019, Vol. 40, N° 5, p. 725-744.
- Castoriadis Cornelius (1997),“Psychoanalysis and Philosophy,” id., The Castoriadis Reader, edited and translated by David Ames Curtis, Oxford, Blackwell, p. 358.
- Contu, Alessia. (2009) Critical management education. In : The Oxford handbook of critical management studies.
- Cordano, Mark; Ellis, Kimberly M.; Scherer, Robert F. (2003), « Natural capitalists : Increasing business students’ environmental sensitivity », Journal of Management Education, Vol. 27, N° 2, p. 144-157.
- Crutzen, Paul J. (2006). The “anthropocene”. In Earth system science in the anthropocene (pp. 13-18). Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg.
- Didier, Christelle; Huet, Romain (2008). « Corporate social responsibility in engineering education. A French survey ». European Journal of Engineering Education Vol. 33, N° 2, p. 169-177.
- Dehler, Gordon E. (2009). « Prospects and possibilities of critical management education : Critical beings and a pedagogy of critical action. » Management Learning, Vol. 40, N° 1, p. 31-49.
- Dryzek, John S. (2013). The politics of the earth : environmental discourses. Oxford university press.
- Ferdinand, Malcolm. (2019). Une écologie décoloniale-Penser l’écologie depuis le monde caribéen. Seuil Anthropocene.
- Fineman, Stephen et Sturdy, Andrew. « The emotions of control : A qualitative exploration of environmental regulation. » Human Relations, 1999, Vol. 52, N° 5, p. 631-663.
- Fournier, Valérie. (2006). « Breaking from the weight of the eternal present : Teaching organizational difference. » Management Learning, 37 (3), p. 295-311.
- Fry, Tony. (2009) Design futuring. University of New South Wales Press, Sydney.
- Gabriel, Yiannis et GRIFFITHS, Dorothy S. « Emotion, learning and organizing. » The learning organization, 2002.
- Gaonkar, Dilip Parameshwar. (2002) « Toward New Imaginaries : An Introduction. » Public Culture 14(1) : p. 1-19.
- Gasparin, Marta, Zalasiewicz, Jan et al. (2020). « The business school in the Anthropocene : Parasite logic and pataphysical reasoning for a working earth. » Academy of Management Learning & Education, 19(3), p. 385-405.
- Ghosh, Amitav (2018). The great derangement : Climate change and the unthinkable. Penguin UK.
- Grey, Chris, French, Robert (1996). Rethinking management education : An introduction. Rethinking management education, Vol 14, p. 1-16.
- Grey, Chris (2004). « Reinventing business schools : The contribution of critical management education », Academy of Management Learning & Education, vol 3, N° 2, p. 178-186.
- Haraway, Donna. (2015). « Anthropocene, Capitalocene, Plantationocene, Chthulucene : Making kin ». Environmental Humanities 6 (1) : p. 159-165
- Heizmann, Helena, Liu, Helena. (2018). « Becoming green, becoming leaders : Identity narratives in sustainability leadership development. » Management Learning, 49(1), p. 40-58.
- Howard, Thomas; Cornuel, Eric (2012). « Business schools in transition ? Issues of impact, legitimacy, capabilities and re-invention », Journal of Management Development, Vol. 31, N° 4, p. 329-335.
- Huckle, John; Sterling, Stephen (1996). Education for sustainability. Earthscan.
- Jessop, Bob. (2004) ‘Critical Semiotic Analysis and Cultural Political Economy’, Critical Discourse Studies 1(2) : p. 159-74.
- Khurana, Rakesh (2007). From Higher Aims to Hired Hands : The Social Transformation of American Business Schools and the Unfulfilled Promise of Management as a Profession. Princeton University Press, Princeton, 509 p.
- Khurana, Rakesh; Snook, Scott (2011) « Identity Work in Business Schools : From Don Quixote, to Dons and Divas », Journal of Management Inquiry, Vol. 20, N° 4, p. 358-361.
- Latour, Bruno (2015). Face à Gaia. La Découverte.
- Latour, Bruno (2017). Où atterrir ?, La Découverte.
- Levy, David. L., & Egan, Daniel. (2003). A neo-Gramscian approach to corporate political strategy : conflict and accommodation in the climate change negotiations. Journal of Management Studies, 40(4), p. 803-829.
- Levy, David. L., & Lichtenstein, Benyamin. (2012). « Approaching business and the environment with complexity theory. » In The oxford handbook of business and the natural environment.
- Levy, David L.; Spicer, André (2013). « Contested imaginaries and the cultural political economy of climate change », Organization, Vol. 20, N° 5, p. 659-678.
- Luke, Timothy (1999). Eco-managerialism : environmental studies as a power/knowledge formation. In Fischer F. and Hajer M. Living with nature : Environmental politics as cultural discourse, p. 103-120, Oxford University Press.
- Malm, Andreas. (2016) Fossil capital : The rise of steam power and the roots of global warming. Verso Books.
- Moore, Jason W. (2017). “The Capitalocene, Part I : on the nature and origins of our ecological crisis.” The Journal of peasant studies 44.3 : p. 594-630.
- Mora, Camilo, et al. (2017) « Global risk of deadly heat. » Nature Climate Change 7.7 : p. 501.
- Mora, Camilo, et al. (2018) « Broad threat to humanity from cumulative climate hazards intensified by greenhouse gas emissions. » Nature Climate Change 8.12 : p. 1062-1071.
- Morton, Timothy (2013). Hyperobjects : Philosophy and Ecology after the End of the World. U of Minnesota Press.
- Muff, Katrin. (2013) « Developing globally responsible leaders in business schools : A vision and transformational practice for the journey ahead. » Journal of Management Development 32.5 : p. 487-507.
- Muniesa, Fabian, Millo, Yuval, & Callon, Michel. (2007) « An introduction to market devices. » The sociological review, 55(2_suppl), p. 1-12.
- Newton, Tim, & HARTE, George (1997) « Green business : technicist kitsch ? » Journal of Management Studies, 34(1), p. 75-98.
- Newton, Tim (2009). « Organizations and the natural environment. » in Alvesson, M., Bridgman, T. and Willmott, H. The Oxford Handbook of Critical Management Studies, p. 125-143.
- Lederer, Markus, & Kreuter, Judith (2018). « Organising the unthinkable in times of crises : Will climate engineering become the weapon of last resort in the Anthropocene ? » Organization, 25(4), p. 472-490.
- Lewis, Simon L; Maslin, Mark (2015). « Defining the Anthropocene », Nature, Vol. 519, N° 7542, p. 171-180.
- Ortiz, Horacio, Muniesa, Fabian (2018). « Business schools, the anxiety of finance, and the order of the ’middle teer », Journal of Cultural Economy, Vol. 11, N° 1, p. 1-19.
- Reynolds, Michael (1999). « Critical reflection and management education : Rehabilitating less hierarchical approaches », Journal of Management Education, Vol. 23, N° 5, p. 537-553.
- Roux-Rosier, Anahid, Azambuja, Ricardo and Gazi Islam (2018). “Alternative visions : Permaculture as imaginaries of the Anthropocene.” Organization 25.4 : p. 550-572.
- Rowlinson, Michael; Hassard, John (2011). « How come the critters come to be teaching in business schools ? », Organization, Vol. 18, N° 15, p. 673-689.
- Scherer, Andreas Georg, (2008) « Critical Theory and its Contribution to Critical Management Studies » in, M. Alvesson, H. Willmott, T. Bridgman, eds., The Oxford Handbook of Critical Management Studies. p. 29-51, Oxford University Press.
- Shrivastava, Paul (1994). « Greening Business Education, Toward an Ecocentric Pedagogy », Journal of Management Inquiry, Vol. 3, N° 3, p.235-243.
- Shrivastava, Paul (2010). « Pedagogy of Passion for Sustainability », Academy of Management Learning & Education, Vol. 9, N° 3, p. 443-455.
- Somerville, Margaret (2017). « The Anthropocene’s call to educational research », dans K. Malone, Karen, Truong Son et GRAY Tonia. (sous la direction de), Reimagining sustainability in precarious times, Springer, Singapore, p. 17-28.
- Rowell, A. ( 2007) « Exxon’s Foot Soldiers : The Case of the International Policy Network », p. 94-116 in W. Dinan and D. Miller (eds) Thinker, Faker, Spinner, Spy : Corporate PR and the Assault on Democracy. London : Pluto Press.
- Steffen, Will; Grinevald, Jacques; Crutzen, Paul; Mcneill, John (2011). « The Anthropocene : conceptual and historical perspectives », Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society,A Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences, Vol. 369, N° 1938, p. 842-867.
- Steffen, Will; Broadgate, Wendy; Deutsch, Lisa; Gaffney Owen; Ludwig, Cornelia (2015). « The trajectory of the Anthropocene : the great acceleration », The Anthropocene Review, Vol. 2, N° 1, p. 81-98.
- Straume, Ingrid (2011). The political imaginary of global capitalism. Depoliticization : The political imaginary of global capitalism, 2011, p. 27-50.
- Strauss, Claudia (2006). « The imaginary », Anthropological theory, Vol. 6, N° 3, p. 322-344..
- Taylor, Charles (2004). Modern social imaginaries. Duke University Press.
- Taskin, Laurent, Willmott, Hugh (2008). « Introducing critical management studies : Key dimensions », Gestion 2000, Vol. 25, N° 10, p. 27-38.
- Tasset, Cyprien (2019). « Arts de mourir et arts de savoir dans l’Anthropocène », Critique, Vol. 1, p. 101-110.
- Thomas, Tom E. (2005). « Are Business Students Buying It ? A theoretical Framework for Measuring Attitudes Toward the Legitimacy of Environmental Sustainability », Business Strategy and the Environment, Vol. 14, N° 3, p. 186-197
- Thomas, Howard (2007). « Business school strategy and the metrics for success », Journal of Management Development, Vol. 26, N° 1, p. 33-42.
- Thomas, Howard; Cornuel, Eric (2012). « Business schools in transition ? Issues of impact, legitimacy, capabilities and re-invention », Journal of Management Development, Vol. 31, N° 4, p. 329-335.
- Vickers, D. A. (2019). « At-home ethnography : a method for practitioners. » Qualitative Research in Organizations and Management : An International Journal.
- Vince, Russ. (2001). « Power and Emotion in Organisational Learning » Human Relations 54, p. 1325-1351.
- Vince, Russ. (2010). « Anxiety, politics and critical management education. » British Journal of Management, Vol. 21, p. s 26-s39.
- Wang, Yutao; Shi, Han; Sun, Mingxing; Huisingh, Donald; Hansson, Lars; Wang, Renqing (2013). « Moving towards an ecologically sound society ? Starting from green universities and environmental higher education », Journal of Cleaner Production, Vol. 61, p. 1-5.
- Waters, Colin N.; Zalasiewicz, Jan (2018). « Concrete : The Most Abundant Novel Rock Type of the Anthropocene », dans D.A DellaSala et M.I Goldstein (sous la direction de), Encyclopedia of the Anthropocene, Volume 1 Geologic, History and Energy, Elsevier, p. 75-85.
- Weick, Karl E. (1995). Sensemaking in Organizations, SAGE Publications, 231 p.
- Wittneben Bettina B. F.; Okereke Chukwumerije; Banerjee Subhabrata Bobby; Levy David L. (2012) « Climate Change and the Emergence of New Organizational Landscapes. » Organization Studies.;33(11) : p. 1431-1450.
- Whiteman, Gail; Walker, Brian & Perego, Paolo. (2013) « Planetary Boundaries : Ecological Foundations for Corporate Sustainability », Journal of Management Studies 50(2) : p. 307-36.
- Wright, C., Nyberg, D., De Cock, C., & Whiteman, G. (2013). « Future imaginings : organizing in response to climate change. » Organization, 20(5), p. 647-658.
- Wright, Christopher, & Nyberg, Daniel. (2015). Climate change, capitalism, and corporations. Cambridge University Press.
- Wright, Christopher; Nyberg, Daniel; Rickards, Lauren, & Freund, James. (2018).”Organizing in the Anthropocene”.Organization, 25(4).
- Yusoff, Kathryn (2018). A billion black Anthropocenes or none. U of Minnesota Press.
- Zalasiewicz, Jan; Waters, Colin N.; … Haff, Peter K. (2015). « When did the Anthropocene begin ? », Quaternary International. Vol. 383, p. 196-203.
- Zalasiewicz, Jan; Waters, Colin N.; … Haff, Peter K. (2017). « The Working Group on the Anthropocene : Summary of evidence and interim recommendations », Anthropocene, Vol. 19, p. 55-60.