The exhibition catalogue as a form can be an odd little hybrid. Long after the exhibition has been struck, and objects returned to owners or the vault, the catalogue remains, recording the absence of presence through image and text. Sometimes it appears after the exhibition has closed, subject to the instability of gallery funding and tight time lines. Design considerations, the quality and numbers of the visual images determine how we view the catalogue and make meaning of its arrangement of images, texts and ideas. Given the competing mandates of writers, curators, designers, donors, institutions, patrons, and art councils; the exhibition catalogue as published by the art museum or gallery is, to borrow a concept from Freud, overdetermined. It is a record sometimes more, sometimes less, faithful to the exhibition experience. But verisimilitude to that experience is not necessarily the criterion of excellence when evaluating exhibition catalogues. Scholarship and new research are important components of the art writing held between the covers. Often, new data is brought to the fore by art historians and curators. The objects in question are re-contextualized or re-considered based on aesthetic and extra-aesthetic concerns. The essays extend the reach of the exhibition and set the ambulatory narrative of physical objects in space into textual form with description and argumentation. Such art writing, research and interpretation is of interest to connoisseurs, commercial dealers, donors, patrons, museologists, and academics. Is the purpose of the exhibition to extend connoisseurship? If so, then the bringing together of discrete objects for the benefit of close visual inspection is important for both exhibition and catalogue. Are the exhibition and catalogue part of the process of institutional or individual aggrandizement? If so, then it is more likely that boosterism rather than arguments of substance will be encountered therein. The look and feel of the exhibition catalogue is borne of its institutional relationship to the host museum or gallery. The semiotic strategies may demand a director’s waving of the flag, symbols of various art council logos, and acknowledgements of past productions. One of the catalogues under discussion here, Rankin Inlet Ceramics (Wight 2003) published by the Winnipeg Art Gallery (WAG), is similar in scale and shape to the well known series of exhibitions and catalogues that the WAG produced in the late 1970s and early 1980s. Slim enough to be slipped into a handbag or a pocket, these were devoted to the work of individual communities and included small but copious illustrations and relevant essays by Inuit Art experts and practitioners. They were guides for connoisseurs and dealers to help distinguish the style, iconography and materials of one community as distinct from another. For example, the community or region, such as Port Harrison/Inoucdjouac (Inukjuak) or Rankin Inlet/Kangiqliniq served as an organizing principle for both exhibition and catalogue (Blodgett et al. 1977; Selby et al. 1981). As noted by then WAG curator Jean Blodgett in 1977, for the Port Harrison exhibition catalogue: The impetus for exhibitions of community based arts flows from the introduction of Eskimo Art to a southern audience in the 1950s. From organizing principle to causal explanation, the region exerts a determining influence on style. Regional stylistic continuities are found as a result of the flavour and texture of local stone, the shared experiences in the context of a particularly forceful art adviser, or a media-based practice. More typically in art historical approaches to Inuit Art, the methodology integrates the influences exerted by communities and the special artistic abilities of individual artists in discussions of style (Hessel and Routledge 1993). The mother and child sculptures from Salluit in the 1950s, …
Appendices
References
- BARBER, Bruce, Serge GUILBAUT and John O’BRIAN (eds), 1996 Voices of Fire: Art, Rage, Power, and the State, Toronto, University of Toronto Press.
- BLODGETT, Jean, 1976 Tuu’luq/Anguhadluq, Exhibition catalogue, Winnipeg, The Winnipeg Art Gallery.
- BLODGETT, Jean et al., 1977 Port Harrison/Inoucdjouac, Exhibition catalogue, Winnipeg, The Winnipeg Art Gallery.
- BUTLER, Sheila, 1972 Wall Hangings from Baker Lake, The Beaver, 302(2): 26-31.
- CANADA COUNCIL FOR THE ARTS, 2004 Grant Programs, Writing and Publishing, Emerging Publisher Grants and Block Grants. http://www.canadacouncil.ca/grants/ publishing/wrsh01-e.asp
- CLIFFORD, James, Virginia DOMINGEZ and Trinh T. MINH-HA, 1987 Of Other People’s: Beyond the Salvage Paradigm, in Hal Foster (ed.), Discussions in Contemporary Culture, Seattle, Bay Area Press: 121-150.
- GRABURN, Nelson, 1987 Reflections of an Anthropologist, in Marion Jackson and Judith Nasby (eds), Contemporary Inuit Drawings, Guelph, MacDonald Stewart Art Centre: 21-29.
- HESSEL, Ingo and Marie ROUTLEDGE, 1993 Contemporary Inuit Sculpture: An Approach to the Medium, the Artists and their Work, in Canadian Museum of Civilization (ed.), In the Shadow of theSun: Perspective on Contemporary Native Art, Hull, Canadian Museum of Civilization, Canadian Ethnology Service, Mercury Series, 124: 443-447.
- INDIAN AND NORTHERN AFFAIRS, 1993 Keeping Our Stories Alive: The Sculpture of Canada’s Inuit, video, Hull, Indian and Northern Affairs, Inuir Art Section.
- LEROUX, Odette, Marion E. JACKSON and Minnie Aodla FREEMAN (eds), 1994 Inuit Women Artists, Vancouver, Douglas and McIntyre.
- PREZIOSI, Donald, 1989 Rethinking Art History: Meditations on a Coy Science, New Haven, Yale University Press.
- ROUTLEDGE, Marie, 2002 Examining the Fabric of Art and Life, in Marie Bouchard, Marion Tuu’luq, Exhibition catalogue, Ottawa, National Gallery of Canada: 10-15.
- SELBY, Roger et al., 1981 Rankin Inlet/Kangirlliniq, Exhibition catalogue, Winnipeg, The Winnipeg Art Gallery.
- SWINTON, George, 1972 Sculpture of the Eskimo, Toronto, McClelland and Stewart.
- SWINTON, George, 1992 Sculpture of the Inuit, Toronto, McClelland and Stewart.
- WIGHT, Darlene, 1990 The First Passionate Collector: The Ian Lindsay Collection of Inuit Art, Exhibition catalogue, Winnipeg, The Winnipeg Art Gallery.