Abstracts
Résumé
La Chine, comme de nombreux autres pays, a reconnu la nécessité d’aligner le progrès scientifique national sur celui du développement mondial. Comme elle avance à grands pas sur la voie du développement scientifique, l’une des principales préoccupations de la communauté scientifique internationale est la façon dont la Chine va transformer l’atlas des sciences actuel. Basé sur une étude menée dans six villes chinoises, l’article utilise surtout la théorie du cosmopolitisme d’Ulrich Beck pour examiner le développement des sciences de la vie en Chine durant la dernière décennie. Il voit ainsi comment les Chinois ont acquis une sensibilité (cosmopolite) aux méthodes de raisonnement scientifique qui leur sont étrangères et comment ils ont contribué à la « cosmopolitisation » de la science.
Mots-clés:
- Chine,
- développement scientifique,
- gouvernance mondiale,
- cosmopolitisme
Abstract
China is one among many other countries that have recognised the necessity in aligning national scientific progress with that of global development. As China is striding along the path of scientific development with determination and initial success, a key concern confronted by international scientific community is how China will transform existing global scientific atlas. Based on a project carried out in six Chinese cities, this paper mainly employs Ulrich Beck’s cosmopolitan theory in examining China’s life sciences’ development in the last decade to investigate how Chinese stakeholders have developed a (cosmopolitan) sensibility to rival ways of scientific reasoning, and in what way Chinese stakeholders have contributed to the cosmopolitanization of science.
Keywords:
- China,
- scientific development,
- global governance,
- cosmopolitanism
Appendices
Bibliographie
- Abbott Alison et David Cyranoski, 2001, « China Plans “Hybrid” Embryonic Stem Cells », Nature, vol. 413, no 6854 : 339.
- Appiah Kwame Anthony, 2006, Cosmopolitanism. Ethics in a World of Strangers, Londres, Penguin.
- Appiah Kwame Anthony, 2007, The Ethics of Identity, Princeton, Princeton University Press.
- Beck Ulrich1996. ‘World Risk Society as Cosmopolitan Society?’, Theory, Culture and Society, 13 (4) : 1-32
- Beck Ulrich, 2000, « The Cosmopolitan Perspective. Sociology in the Second Age of Modernity », British Journal of Sociology, vol. 51, no 1 : 79-105.
- Beck Ulrich, 2002. « The Cosmopolitan Society and Its Enemies », Theory Culture & Society vol. 19, nos 1-2 : 17
- Beck Ulrich, 2006, The Cosmopolitan Vision, Cambridge, Polity Press.
- Beck Ulrich, 2008, « Risk Society’s “Cosmopolitan Moment” », conférence à l’Université de Harvard, Harvard, 12 novembre.
- Boesz Christine et Nigel Lloyd, 2008, « Investigating International Misconduct », Nature, vol. 452, no 7188 : 686-687.
- Bohman James, 2007, Democracy across Borders. From Dêmos to Dêmoi, Cambridge, ma, mit Press.
- Borger Julian, 2001, « Bush Compromise Allows Stem Cell Research in US », The Guardian, 10 août. Consulté sur Internet (www.guardian.co.uk/world/2001/aug/10/medicalscience.usa) le 12 novembre 2010.
- Cairncross Frances, 1997, The Death of Distance: How the Communications Revolution Will Change Our Lives, Londres, Orion Business Books.
- Cao Cong et Richard P. Suttmeier, 2001, « China’s New Scientific Elite. Distinguished Young Scientists, the Research Environment and Hopes for Chinese Science », China Quarterly, vol. 168 : 960-984.
- Chan Kwok-Bun, 2002, « Both Sides, Now. Culture Contact, Hybridization, and Cosmopolitanism, dans S. Vertovec et R. Cohen (dir.), Conceiving Cosmopolitanism. Theory, Context and Practice, Oxford, Oxford University Press : 191-208.
- Charmaz Kathy, 2006, Constructing Grounded Theory. A Practical Guide through Qualitative Analysis, Londres, Sage Publications.
- Chen Haidan, 2009, « Stem Cell Governance in China. From Bench to Bedside ? », New Genetics and Society, vol. 28, no 3 : 267-282.
- Chen Ying, Zhi Xu Shenget al., 2003, « Embryonic Stem Cells Generated by Nuclear Transfer of Human Somatic Nuclei into Rabbit Oocytes », Cell Research, vol. 13, no 4 : 251-264.
- Chen Zhu, Hong-Guang Wang, Zhao-Jun Wen et Yihuang Wang, 2007, « Life Science and Biotechnology in China », Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, vol. 362, no 1482 : 947-957.
- Cheng Linzhao, Ren-Zong Qiu, Hongkui Deng, Y.A. Zhang, Ying Jin et Lingsong Li, 2006, « Ethics. China Already Has Clear Stem-cell Guidelines », Nature, vol. 440, no 7187 : 992.
- Conley, Verena Andermatt, 2002, « Chaosmopolis », Theory, Culture & Society, vol. 19, nos 1-2 : 127-138.
- Corbin Juliet M. et Anselm Strauss, 1990, « Grounded Theory Research. Procedures, Canons, and Evaluative Criteria », Qualitative Sociology, vol. 13, no 1 : 3-21.
- Cyranoski David, 2005, « Fetal-cell Therapy. Paper Chase », Nature, vol. 437, no 7060 : 810-811.
- Cyranoski David, 2006, « Patients Warned about Unproven Spinal Surgery », Nature, vol. 440, no 7086 : 850-851.
- Cyranoski David, 2007, « Chinese Network to Start Trials of Spinal Surgery », Nature, vol. 446, no 7135 : 476-477.
- Dahlman Carl J. et Jean-Éric Aubert, 2001, China and the Knowledge Economy. Seizing the 21st Century, Washington, dc, World Bank Publications.
- Dennis Carina, 2002, « China. Stem Cells Rise in the East », Nature, vol. 419, no 6905 : 334-336.
- Dennis Carina, 2003, « Chinese Fusion Method Promises Fresh Route to Human Stem Cells », Nature, vol. 424, no 6950 : 711.
- Doering Ole, 2002, « Social Darwinism, Liberal Eugenics and the Examples of Bioethics in China », dans O. Doering et C. Renbiao (dir.), Advances in Chinese Medical Ethics. Chinese and International Perspectives, Hamburg, Mitteilungen des Instituts fur Asienkunde, no 355.
- dti (Department of Trade and Industry), 2004, Global Watch Mission Report Stem Cell Mission to China, Singapore and South Korea, Report of a dti Global Watch Mission, Londres, Department of Trade and Industry, septembre : 4.
- Enserink Martin, 2006, « Selling the Stem Cell Dream », Science, vol. 313, no 5784 : 160-163.
- chgc (Chinese National Human Genome Centre), 2001, « Ethical Guidelines on Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research (Recommended Draft) », 16 octobre, Chinese Medical Ethics, vol. 6.
- Fox Cynthia, 2007, Cell of Cells. The Global Race to Capture and Control the Stem Cell, New York, ny, W.W. Norton
- Giddens Anthony, 1999, « Risk and Responsibility », The Modern Law Review, vol. 62, no 1 : 1-10.
- Giles Jim, 2006, « Rules Tighten for Stem-cell Studies, Nature, vol. 440, no 7080 : 9.
- Hannerz Ulf, 1990, « Cosmopolitans and Locals in World Culture », Theory, Culture & Society, vol. 7 : 237-251.
- Hao Xin et Yidong Gong, 2006, « China Bets Big on Big Science », Science, vol. 311, no 5767 : 1548-1549.
- Harvey David, 2009, Cosmopolitanism and the Geographies of Freedom, New York, ny, Columbia University Press.
- Henderson Mark, 2007, « The Wild East is Now Tamed. China is Fast Emerging as the New Superpower of Biomedical Research », The Times, 10 février. Consulté sur Internet (women.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/women/body_and_soul/article1359969.ece) le 12 novembre 2010.
- hfea, 2007, hfeaStatement on Its Decision Regarding Hybrid Embryos, 5 septembre. Consulté sur Internet (www.hfea.gov.uk/455.html) le 12 novembre 2010.
- Highfield Roger, 2001, « Boy’s dna Implanted in Rabbit Eggs », Daily Telegraph, 27 septembre. Consulté sur Internet (www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/china/1357755/Boys-DNA-implanted-in-rabbit-eggs.html) le 12 novembre 2010.
- Horton Richard, 2006, « The Coming Decade for Global Action on Child Health », Lancet, 367(9504) : 3-5.
- Hu Jintao, 2006, Stick to the Road to Independent Innovations with Chinese Characteristics, and Exert Every Effort to Build an Innovation-Oriented Country, Beijing, National Science and Technology Assembly, 9 janvier.
- Hutton Will, 2007, The Writing on the Wall. China and the West in the 21st Century, Londres, Little, Brown & Company.
- isscr (International Society of Stem Cell Research), 2008, isscr Guidelines for the Clinical Translation of Stem Cell Research, 3 décembre.
- Ji Shisan, 2007, « We Did World’s First Case on Human-Animal Hybrid Embryos ! », Nanfang Weekend, 27 septembre. Consulté sur Internet (tech.sina.com.cn/d/2007-09-27/11081766396.shtml) le 12 novembre 2010.
- Johnson Mark. 2008, « Stem Cell Scientists Urge Clinical Trials in us »,The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, 24 septembre. Consulté sur Internet (www.jsonline.com/news/wisconsin/32492559.html) le 12 novembre 2010.
- Larson Charles F., 2004, « Institutional Development in China’s Science & Technology », International Symposium on Transforming Institutions in Global China, University of Maryland, 1er mai.
- Mandavilli Apoorva, 2006, « Profile. Hui Zhen Sheng », Nature Medicine, vol. 12, no 3 : 265.
- Manning Stephan, Silvia Massini et Arie Y. Lewin, 2008, « A Dynamic Perspective on Next-Generation Offshoring. The Global Sourcing of Science and Engineering Talent », Academy of Management Perspectives, vol. 22, no 3, août : 35-54.
- Mau Steffen, Jan Mewes et Ann Zimmermann, 2008, « Cosmopolitan Attitudes through Transnational Social Practices ? », Global Networks, vol. 8, no 1 : 1-24.
- mae (Ministry of Foreign Affairs), 2003, China’s Science and Technology Development Summary. Consulté sur Internet (id.china-embassy.org/eng/kjjl/t87396.htm) le 12 novembre 2010.
- mst (Ministry of Science and Technology) (2003) « The Ethical Guidelines for Research on Human Embryonic Stem Cells », Stem Cells Guideline.
- Mu Rongping et Wan Qu, 2008, « The Development of Science and Technology in China. A comparison with India and the United States », Technology in Society, vol. 30, nos 3-4 : 319-329.
- Murray Fiona et Debora Spar, 2006, « Bit Player or Powerhouse ? China and Stem-Cell Research », New England Journal of Medicine, 21 septembre : 1191-1194.
- Nie Cuirong, 2003, « Special Focus. Sheng Huizhen is Leading the Race in Therapeutic Embryonic Cloning », Science and Technology Daily, 27 août.
- ocde, 2007a, Main Science and Technology Indicators 2007/2.
- ocde, 2007b, « Best Practices for Ensuring Scientific Integrity and Preventing Misconduct », Global Science Forum, Tokyo, 22-23 février.
- Qiu Jane, 2007, « To Walk Again », New Scientist, 10 novembre : 57-59.
- Qiu Jane, 2009, « China Spinal Cord Injury Network. Changes from Within », Lancet, vol. 8 : 606-607.
- Roudometof Victor, 2005, « Transnationalism, Cosmopolitanism and Glocalization », Current Sociology, vol. 53, no 1 : 113-135.
- Salter Brian, 2007, « The Global Politics of Human Embryonic Stem Cell Science », Global Governance, vol. 13: 277-298.
- Singer Emily, 2006, « Spinal Cord Cures in China », Technology Review, 18 avril. Consulté sur Internet (www.technologyreview.com/read_article.aspx?id=16708&ch=biotech&pg=1) le 12 novembre 2010.
- State Council, 2006, The National Mid-term and Long-term Science and Technology Development Plan 2006-2020, 9 février, Beijing.
- Tomlinson Heather et David Adam, 2005, « China Surges Ahead in Stem Cell Science », The Guardian, 24 janvier. Consulté sur Internet (www.guardian.co.uk/science/2005/jan/24/sciencenews.science) le 12 novembre 2010.
- unesco, 2008, Bangkok Regional Unit for Social and Human Science in Asia and the Pacific Asia Pacific Perspectives on Biotechnology and Bioethics, Bangkok.
- uksci, 2005a, uk Stem Cell Initiative: Report and Recommendations, novembre, Londres.
- uksci, 2005b, uk Stem Cell Initiative. Global Positions in Stem Cell Research. China, 24 novembre. Consulté sur Internet (www.advisorybodies.doh.gov.uk/uksci/global/china.htm) le 12 novembre 2010.
- Wagner Caroline S., 2008, The New Invisible College, Washington, dc, Brookings Institution Press.
- Wainwright Steven P., Clare Williams, Mike Michael, Bobbie Farsides et Alan Cribb, 2006, « Ethical Boundary-work in the Embryonic Stem Cell Laboratory », Sociology of Health & Illness, vol. 28, no 6 : 732-748.
- Walsh Fergus, 2008, « uk’s First Hybrid Embryos Created », bbc, 1er avril. Consulté sur Internet (news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/7323298.stm) le 12 novembre 2010.
- Wang Dapeng, 2008, « The Earliest Human-Animal Embryo. We’d Created Human-Rabbit Embryos Five Years Ago », Beijing Morning Post, 3 avril. Consulté sur Internet (tech.sina.com.cn/d/2008-04-03/03252117070.shtml) le 12 novembre 2010.
- Wang Yanguang, 2003, « Chinese Ethical Views on Embryo Stem (es) Cell Research », dans S.Y. Song, Y.M. Koo, D.R.J. Macer (dir.), Asian Bioethics in the 21st Century. Consulté sur Internet (www2.unescobkk.org/eubios/ABC4/abc4049.htm) le 12 novembre 2010.
- Yang Xiangzhong, 2004, « An Embryo Nation », Nature, vol. 428, no 6979 : 210-212.
- You Xueqing et Lizi Zhang, 2001, « Human-Rabbit Hybrid Caused Dispute », Science and Technology Daily (Keji Ribao), 20 septembre.
- Zhang Joy Yueyue, 2008, Research on Good Governance in China, bionet.
- Zhang Joy Yueyue, 2009, « The Regulation of China’s Stem Cell Research in the Context of Cosmopolitanization », dans O. Doering (dir.), Life Sciences in Translation. A Sino-European Dialogue on Ethical Governance of the Life Sciences, septembre, Londres, bionet.
- Zhang Joy Yueyue, 2010, « The Organization of Scientists and Its Relation to Scientific Productivity. Perceptions of Chinese Stem Cell Researchers », Biosocieties, vol. 5, no 2 : 219-235.
- Zhang Leren et Yunyan Zhang Chen, 2001, « Major Breakthrough for Therapeutic Cloning. Sun Yat-sen Medical University Cloned More than 100 Human Embryos Using New Technology », People’s Daily, Southern China News, 7 septembre. Consulté sur Internet (www.peopledaily.com.cn/GB/paper49/4169/485725.html) le 12 novembre 2010.
- Zhang Shumei, 2008, « uk Sanctioned Human-Animal Embryo Research. A Fulfilment beyond Science », Nanfang Daily, 23 janvier : A06. Consulté sur Internet (epaper.nfdaily.cn/html/2008-01/23/node_7.htm) le 12 novembre 2010.