Abstracts
Abstract
Despite being a unique aspect of ageing in capitalist societies, retirement has been neglected within critical research. As a disruption in people’s relation to the capitalist political economy, retirement can be framed through a productivist lens of loss or ruin. Yet, in this article, I explore the practices of commoning that emerge amongst retired urban gardeners which defy and resist this capitalist logic. I argue that retired gardeners practice forms of de-alienation, which are the processes and practices of rehabilitation and repair following decades of alienation that have become imprinted on people’s bodies, minds, and social lives—and much more—throughout the lifecourse. Through the inter-relationship between social, spatial, and creative de-alienation, retired urban gardeners generate and sustain more-than-capitalist subjectivities and experiment with alternative value practices. In doing so, the article introduces the concept of lifecourse commoning, which considers the way that practices of commoning might emerge, recede, or change shape as people’s relation to capitalism changes through the lifecourse.
Keywords:
- commoning,
- retirement,
- urban gardens,
- lifecourse,
- de-alienation,
- allotments
Appendices
Bibliography
- Åberg, Ida. 2019. ‘Imagining Urban Gardening Space: An Ethnographic Study of Urban Gardening in Sweden’. Thesis, Linköping University, Sweden.
- Acton, Lesley. 2011. ‘Allotment Gardens: A Reflection of History, Heritage, Community and Self’. Papers from the Institute of Archaeology 21 (December):46.
- Allen, Mike. 2017. The SAGE Encyclopedia of Communication Research Methods. 4 vols. SAGE Publications.
- Bach, Claire E, and Nathan McClintock. 2021. ‘Reclaiming the City One Plot at a Time? DIY Garden Projects, Radical Democracy, and the Politics of Spatial Appropriation’. Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space 39 (5): 859–78.
- Barron, Jennifer. 2017. ‘Community Gardening: Cultivating Subjectivities, Space, and Justice’. Local Environment 22 (9): 1142–58.
- Bergame, Nathalie. 2023a. ‘Acknowledging Contradictions – Endorsing Change: Transforming the Urban Through Gardening’. Capitalism Nature Socialism 34 (1): 69–87.
- Bergame, Nathalie. 2023b. ‘Cultivating Commoner Subjectivities and Transforming Agency in Commoned Urban Gardens’. Geoforum 141 (May):103725.
- Bhattacharya, Tithi. 2017. ‘Introduction’. In Social Reproduction Theory: Remapping Class, Recentering Oppression, edited by Tithi Bhattacharya. Mapping Social Reproduction Theory Series. Pluto Press.
- Bresnihan, Patrick, and Michael Byrne. 2015. ‘Escape into the City: Everyday Practices of Commoning and the Production of Urban Space in Dublin’. Antipode 47 (1): 36–54.
- Brownhill, Leigh, Terisa E. Turner, and Wahu Kaara. 2012. ‘Degrowth? How About Some “De-Alienation”?’ Capitalism Nature Socialism 23 (1): 93–104.
- Buffel, Tine, Sophie Yarker, Chris Phillipson, Luciana Lang, Camilla Lewis, Patty Doran, and Mhorag Goff. 2023. ‘Locked down by Inequality: Older People and the COVID-19 Pandemic’. Urban Studies 60 (8): 1465–82.
- Burdon, Peter, and James Martel. 2017. ‘Environmentalism and an Anarchist Research Method’. In Research Methods in Environmental Law: A Handbook, by A. Philippopoulos-Mihalopoulos and V. Brooks. Handbooks of Research Methods in Law Series. Edward Elgar Publishing.
- Caffentzis, George. 2010. ‘The Future of “The Commons”: Neoliberalism’s “Plan B” or the Original Disaccumulation of Capital?’ New Formations 69 (1): 23–41.
- Cardiff Council. 2022. ‘Cardiff Allotment Strategy 2022-2027 (Draft)’. Accessed November 1, 2023. https://cardiff.moderngov.co.uk/documents/s56480/Cabinet%2010%20March%202022%20Allotment%20Strat%20App%20A.pdf.
- Certomà, Chiara, and Paolo Giaccaria. 2023. ‘Dialogic Practices of Urban Gardening in Rome: “Reading for Difference” in Social Innovation’. Urban Geography 45 (2): 258–280.
- Certomà, Chiara, and Chiara Tornaghi. 2015. ‘Political Gardening. Transforming Cities and Political Agency’. Local Environment 20 (10): 1123–31.
- Chatterton, Paul, and Andre Pusey. 2019. ‘Beyond Capitalist Enclosure, Commodification and Alienation: Postcapitalist Praxis as Commons, Social Production and Useful Doing’. Progress in Human Geography 44 (1): 27–48.
- Cleaver, Harry. 1992. ‘The Inversion of Class Perspective in Marxian Theory: From Valorisation to Self-Valorisation’. In Open Marxism, Volume 2; Theory and Practice, edited by John Holloway, Werner Bonefeld, and Kosmas Psychopedis. Pluto.
- Corcoran, Mary, Patricia Kettle, and Cian O’Callaghan. 2017. ‘Green Shoots in Vacant Plots? Urban Agriculture and Austerity in Post-Crash Ireland’. ACME: An International Journal for Critical Geographies 16 (2): 305–31.
- Crossan, John, Andrew Cumbers, Robert McMaster, and Deirdre Shaw. 2016. ‘Contesting Neoliberal Urbanism in Glasgow’s Community Gardens: The Practice of DIY Citizenship’. Antipode 48 (4): 937–55.
- Crouch, David, and Colin Ward. 1997. The Allotment: Its Landscape and Culture. Five Leaves.
- Cumbers, Andrew. 2015. ‘Constructing a Global Commons in, against and beyond the State’. Space and Polity 19 (1): 62–75.
- Cumbers, Andrew, Deirdre Shaw, John Crossan, and Robert McMaster. 2017. ‘The Work of Community Gardens: Reclaiming Place for Community in the City’. Work, Employment and Society 32 (1): 133–49.
- Dawney, Leila. 2017. ‘On Finding Hope beyond Progress’. In Problems of Hope, edited by Claire Blencowe, Patrick Bresnihan, and Leila Dawney, 11–29. ARN Press.
- De Angelis, Massimo. 2004. ‘Separating the Doing and the Deed: Capital and the Continuous Character of Enclosures’. Historical Materialism-Research in Critical Marxist Theory 12 (2): 57–87.
- De Angelis, Massimo. 2014. ‘Social Revolution and the Commons’. South Atlantic Quarterly 113 (2): 299–311.
- De Angelis, Massimo. 2017. Omnia Sunt Communia: On the Commons and the Transformation to Postcapitalism. Zed Books.
- DeSilvey, Caitlin. 2003. ‘Cultivated Histories in a Scottish Allotment Garden’. Cultural Geographies 10 (4): 442–68.
- Dombroski, Kelly, David Conradson, Gradon Diprose, Stephen Healy, and Amanda Yates. 2023. ‘Cultivating Commoners: Infrastructures and Subjectivities for a Postcapitalist Counter-City’. Cities 143 (7): 104635.
- Eizenberg, Efrat. 2012. ‘Actually Existing Commons: Three Moments of Space of Community Gardens in New York City’. Antipode 44 (3): 764–82.
- Engel-Di Mauro, Salvatore. 2018. ‘Urban Community Gardens, Commons, and Social Reproduction: Revisiting Silvia Federici’s Revolution at Point Zero’. Gender, Place & Culture 25 (9): 1379–90.
- Evans, Daniel., Kieron Smith, and Huw Williams, eds. 2021. The Welsh Way: Essays on Neoliberalism and Devolution. Parthian Books.
- Fantini, Andrea. 2023. ‘Right to the City or Environmental Gentrification? A Discussion about Risks and Potential of Urban Agriculture’. Urban Geography 44 (5), 1003–1010.
- Federici, Silvia. 2018. Re-Enchanting the World: Feminism and the Politics of the Commons. PM Press.
- Ferrari, Elena, Anna Dańkowska, Agnieszka Dragon, Annegret Haase, Jakub Kronenberg, and Dagmar Haase. 2023. ‘Towards an Integrated Garden. Gardeners of All Types, Unite!’ Urban Forestry & Urban Greening 81 (March):127857.
- Fırat, Begüm Özden. 2022. ‘A Double Movement of Enclosure and Commons: Commoning Emek Movie Theatre in Three Acts’. City 26 (5–6): 1029–44.
- Flachs, Andrew. 2013. ‘Gardening as Ethnographic Research: Volunteering as a Means for Community Access’. Journal of Ecological Anthropology 16 (1): 97–103.
- Gardiner, Michael. 2004. ‘Everyday Utopianism: Lefebvre and His Critics’. Cultural Studies 18 (2–3): 228–54.
- Gibson-Graham, J.K. 1996. End of Capitalism (As We Knew It)? Wiley.
- Gibson-Graham, J.K. 2006. A Postcapitalist Politics. University of Minnesota Press.
- Gibson-Graham, J.K., Jenny Cameron, and Stephen Healy. 2016. ‘Commoning as a Postcapitalist Politics’. In Releasing the Commons: Rethinking the Futures of the Commons, edited by Ash Amin and Philip Howell. Routledge.
- Ginn, Franklin. 2012. ‘Dig for Victory! New Histories of Wartime Gardening in Britain’. Journal of Historical Geography 38 (3): 294–305.
- Ginn, Franklin, and Eduardo Ascensão. 2018. ‘Autonomy, Erasure, and Persistence in the Urban Gardening Commons’. Antipode 50 (4): 929–52.
- Graeber, David. 2004. Fragments of an Anarchist Anthropology. Paradigm (Chicago, Ill. : Online). Prickly Paradigm Press.
- Graeber, David, and Andrej Grubačić. 2021. ‘Introduction’. In Mutual Aid: An Illuminated Factor of Evolution, Peter Kropotkin. Kairos Series. PM Press.
- Hardin, Garrett. 1968. ‘The Tragedy of the Commons’. Science 162 (3859): 1243-1248.
- Hastings, Thomas, and Andrew Cumbers. 2019. ‘“That Type of Thing Does Give You a Boost”: Control, Self-Valorisation, and Autonomist Worker Copings in Call Centres’. Antipode 51 (5): 1456–73.
- Heyl, Barbara Sherman. 2001. ‘Ethnographic Interviewing’. In Handbook of Ethnography, by Paul Atkinson, Amanda Coffey, Sara Delamont, John Lolfand, and Lyn Lofland. SAGE Publications Ltd.
- Humphries, Jane. 1990. ‘Enclosures, Common Rights, and Women: The Proletarianization of Families in the Late Eighteenth and Early Nineteenth Centuries’. The Journal of Economic History 50 (1): 17–42.
- Huron, Amanda. 2015. ‘Working with Strangers in Saturated Space: Reclaiming and Maintaining the Urban Commons’. Antipode 47 (4): 963–79.
- Juris, Jeffrey. 2007. ‘Practicing Militant Ethnography with the Movement for Global Resistance in Barcelona’. In Constituent Imagination: Militant Investigations//Collective Theorization, edited by Stevphen Shukaitis, David Graeber, and Erika Biddle. AK Press.
- Kanosvamhira, Tinashe P., Alexander Follmann, and Daniel Tevera. 2024. ‘Experimental Urban Commons?: Re-Examining Urban Community Food Gardens in Cape Town, South Africa’. The Geographical Journal 190 (2): e12553.
- Linebaugh, Peter. 2008. The Magna Carta Manifesto: Liberties and Commons for All. University of California Press.
- Lynch, Kathleen. 2022. Care and Capitalism. Polity Press.
- Malherbe, Nick. 2021. ‘A Psychopolitical Interpretation of De-Alienation: Marxism, Psychoanalysis, and Liberation Psychology’. Psychoanalysis, Culture & Society 26 (3): 263–83.
- Marx, Karl. [1867] 2004. Capital: A Critique of Political Economy. Penguin Books Limited.
- Marx, Karl. [1932] 2011. Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844. Wilder Publications.
- McClintock, Nathan. 2014. ‘Radical, Reformist, and Garden-Variety Neoliberal: Coming to Terms with Urban Agriculture’s Contradictions’. Local Environment 19 (2): 147–71.
- Midnight Notes Collective. 1990. ‘The New Enclosures’. Accessed June 18, 2021. https://libcom.org/files/mn10-new-enclosures.pdf.
- Milbourne, Paul. 2021. ‘Growing Public Spaces in the City: Community Gardening and the Making of New Urban Environments of Publicness’. Urban Studies 58 (14): 2901–19.
- Miller, Ethan. 2015. ‘Anticapitalism or Postcapitalism? Both!’ Rethinking Marxism 27 (3): 364–67.
- Morrow, Oona. 2019. ‘Community Self-Organizing and the Urban Food Commons in Berlin and New York’. Sustainability 11 (13).
- Moselle, Boaz. 1995. ‘Allotments, Enclosure, and Proletarianization in Early Nineteenth-Century Southern England’. The Economic History Review 48 (3): 482–500.
- Müller, Christa. 2012. ‘Practicing Commons in Community Gardens: Urban Gardening as a Corrective for Homo Economicus’. In The Wealth of the Commons: A World Beyond Market and State, edited by David Bollier and Silke Helfrich. Levellers Press.
- Naylor, Lindsay, and Nathan Thayer. 2022. ‘Between Paranoia and Possibility: Diverse Economies and the Decolonial Imperative’. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 47 (3): 791–805.
- Neves, Barbara Barbosa, and Alan Petersen. 2024. ‘The Social Stigma of Loneliness: A Sociological Approach to Understanding the Experiences of Older People’. The Sociological Review 0 (0).
- Noterman, Elsa. 2016. ‘Beyond Tragedy: Differential Commoning in a Manufactured Housing Cooperative’. Antipode 48 (2): 433–52.
- Noterman, Elsa. 2022. ‘Adverse Commoning: Tracing Contested Legal Geographies of the Urban Commons’. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 40 (1): 99–117.
- Ostrom, Elinor. [1990] 2015. Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action. Cambridge University Press.
- Øversveen, Emil. 2022. ‘Capitalism and Alienation: Towards a Marxist Theory of Alienation for the 21st Century’. European Journal of Social Theory 25 (3): 440–57.
- Page, Arnaud. 2017. ‘Meaningful Plots: Leisure, “Rational Recreation” and the Politics of Gardening in British Allotments (Mid 19th-Mid 20th Centuries)’. Angles: New Perspectives on the Anglophone World 5.
- Phillipson, Chris. 2015. ‘The Political Economy of Longevity: Developing New Forms of Solidarity for Later Life’. The Sociological Quarterly 56 (1): 80–100.
- Pudup, Mary Beth. 2008. ‘It Takes a Garden: Cultivating Citizen-Subjects in Organized Garden Projects’. Rethinking Economy 39 (3): 1228–40.
- Purcell, Mark, and Shannon K. Tyman. 2015. ‘Cultivating Food as a Right to the City’. Local Environment 20 (10): 1132–47.
- Raekstad, Paul. 2022. Karl Marx’s Realist Critique of Capitalism: Freedom, Alienation, and Socialism. Palgrave Macmillan.
- Rosol, Marit. 2010. ‘Public Participation in Post-Fordist Urban Green Space Governance: The Case of Community Gardens in Berlin’. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 34 (3): 548–63.
- Ruiz Cayuela, Sergio. 2021. ‘Bridging Materiality and Subjectivity: Expanding the Commons in Cooperation Birmingham’. Antipode 53 (5).
- Ruiz Cayuela, Sergio, and Melissa García-Lamarca. 2023. ‘From the Squat to the Neighbourhood: Popular Infrastructures as Reproductive Urban Commons’. Geoforum 144 (August):103807.
- Rutt, Rebecca. 2020. ‘Cultivating Urban Conviviality: Urban Farming in the Shadows of Copenhagen’s Neoliberalisms’. Journal of Political Ecology 27 (1): 612–34.
- Singh, Neera. 2017. ‘Becoming a Commoner: The Commons as Sites for Affective Socio-Nature Encounters and Co-Becomings’. Ephemeral Journal 17 (4): 751–76.
- Thompson, Matthew. 2015. ‘Between Boundaries: From Commoning and Guerrilla Gardening to Community Land Trust Development in Liverpool’. Antipode 47 (4): 1021–42.
- Thompson, Matthew. 2019. ‘Playing with the Rules of the Game: Social Innovation for Urban Transformation’. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 43 (6): 1168–92.
- Trendov, Nikola M. 2018. ‘Comparative Study on the Motivations That Drive Urban Community Gardens in Central Eastern Europe’. Annals of Agrarian Science 16 (1): 85–89.
- Trott, Ben. 2017. ‘Affective Labour and Alienation: Spinoza’s Materialism and the Sad Passions of Post-Fordist Work’. Emotion, Space and Society 25 (November):119–26.
- Tsing, Anna Lowenhaupt. 2015. The Mushroom at the End of the World: On the Possibility of Life in Capitalist Ruins. New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
- Valle, Gabriel R. 2015. ‘Gardens of Sabotage: Food, the Speed of Capitalism, and the Value of Work’. Aztlan: A Journal of Chicano Studies 40 (1): 63–86.
- Velicu, Irina, and Gustavo García-López. 2018. ‘Thinking the Commons through Ostrom and Butler: Boundedness and Vulnerability’. Theory, Culture & Society 35 (6): 55–73.
- Ward, Colin. [1973] 1996. Anarchy in Action. Freedom Press.
- Williams, Andrew, Mark Goodwin, and Paul Cloke. 2014. ‘Neoliberalism, Big Society, and Progressive Localism’. Environment and Planning A 46 (12): 2798–2815.